Biggest New Forum Mistake

Avoid Selling Out Your New Forum!

In the first two post of the building forums series we talked about starting a forum and choosing the right forum software. Before we get into configuration, optimization and forum strategies let’s cover something very important first.

The one single thing that can kill a new forum before it gets off the ground is trying to make money up front. The only exception to this rule is if you have a huge following, motivated buyers or a tremendous amount of traffic to your site already.

Would you join a new forum packed with ads and pop ups with few or no posts? Avoiding monetizing a new forum is typically a good rule of thumb. It takes time to establish and generate enough content in a new forum to reach critical mass or tipping point. Ads or Hard Selling products makes sense when the forum has thousands of posts and registered users.

Welcome Visitors, Don’t Send Them Away!

The number one reason you do not want to advertise on a brand new forum is really simple and basic. You want to keep users on your site first and foremost for as long as possible instead of sending them off to competitors site in exchange for a few cents.

Think about it, a popular form of revenue is using Google’s AdSense that dynamically displays advertisements on your site. In my experience an average payout on the low end is the between half a cent to maybe five cents. So if you stop to think how hard you’ve worked to generate traffic and get people to your forum to only send them away in exchange for pennies it just doesn’t make sense. The goal of creating a forum is to retain and build returning visitors, not to introduce them to your competitor. Plus allowing competitor advertising on your site is obviously establishing a brand and presence for someone else.

Avoid The Hard Sell

If the goal of creating a new forum is to help sell products then let’s keep that between you and I for now. Even if the forum is an extension of your existing site remember the goal is to generate valuable user generated content.

The hard sell of your product should take place on your main site and not on your forum. By hard selling meaning putting up banners for your products, pop ups for your products or messaging users about your products. This can be a huge turnoff to new members who could find value in your product and your forum.

To clarify hard selling is not the same as branding your forum. Do take the time to make your forum look as close to the design of your main site as possible. Branding is an important part if you’re using your forum as an extension to your existing site. This maybe the first time users become aware of your product or brand. Wouldn’t it be great if the user’s experience of your product for the first time was of a supportive community rather than a pushy hard sell with banner pop ups and advertisements?

Motivate User Generated Content

A new forum should have one goal and that is to build as much quality content as possible in the shortest amount of time. The ideal situation would be if this content was generated by your forum users. The easiest and simplest way to enable users to post is providing an uncluttered path and instructions on how to contribute.

If the first thing new forum visitors see is a pop up ad, banners and/or links to advertisements it is more likely that you’ll lose new users before they can make a contribution to your forum. Here are two sections that should be in a new forum:

Introduce Yourself – It’s a great way for new registered users to share a bit about themselves, their talents and what they hope to contribute or learn from the new forum. Although it is important to reply to most if not all posts at the beginning it is critical that you make it a point to welcome each new visitor when they introduce themselves.

By welcoming each user at least early on to the forum it creates a sense of belonging and secondly it creates a trend for the community. As time goes by the goal would be for established members to welcome new members on their own.

General Conversation – another simple method of motivating users to post early on is giving a bit of liberty to talk about unrelated topics. You may need to watch this forum little closer to prevent people from posting spam or competitive links. Post rules early on to avoid shameless self promotion of competitors products. Rules also help with establishing what is expected from forum users. For example a rule maybe “No Flaming – Answer questions and if you have nothing good to say do not say anything at all. If you are abusive your account will be suspended or banned.”

Don’t Sell Out Your New Forum

Simple things can derail a new forum and keep it from succeeding. Keeping new visitors on your forum is more important than exchanging them for a few cents on AdSense. Motivate users to introduce themselves and post on your forum as this builds return visitors and user generated content. Avoid hard selling users early on instead build your brand and provide a great forum for users to post about your product or related topics.

From "AH YEAH SON!" to "WTF?!?!"
I'm sharing everything on my journey
from $0 to $10k in NEW monthly revenue.

I'm learning a lot and so will you.

Your information will not be shared. Only updates on what we discover will be sent to you, about once a week.

February's Monthly Revenue Update

  • $0
  • $2.5k
  • $5k
  • $7.5k
  • $10k

one comment ( awaiting your reply! )

  • Very good read. It is important to monetize wisely. You definitely don’t want to be inundating visitors with advertisements before your forum is even off the ground.

    -- Lance